"I have a feeling I know why, but I'm not sure you're ready to hear it if you haven't gotten to the why yourself." She reaches to take a swig of the Jack herself. Love is a funny thing. It's also something that screws people up when they haven't admitted or haven't realized that's the cause of some of the problems.
Admitting it was a first step. Maybe he just needed the ability to say it to someone less involved. Though, hiding your heart was easier when you fell into past patterns that made people think you didn't care. That and alcohol. Both were easy. Sansa's happy to give him that ear though, to help him take that step.
"It comes down to what you'd want in the end. Do you want him back, to see if you two could work it out?"
She offered a soft smile. "Sometimes you have to trust that the family bond is stronger than the secrets. If they're all you've got, it means you're all they have too. And even if some time might be needed, family usually gravitates back together after it's healed from any wounds." She nodded in the face of that skeptical look. "I'm sure I really want to hear this."
"Oh, lay it on me," he returned with a wry smile. "I shouldn't want him back. I shouldn't want someone who's ready to believe the worst of me when I..." He looked down at his left hand scarred and little finger unable to fully straighten even ten years later. "We're both broken. I liked to think maybe we could help each other heal, but I think that's just some fairytale bullshit, now."
Because he wasn't the guy who got the happy ending. Nothing had ever worked out for him, and everything that gave a promise of hope was snatched away the second he reached for it. A safe home. College. Alex.
He took the bottle back, taking a much longer swallow. "When we were kids, a lot of...traumatic shit went down. One particular piece of it left Isobel scarred." Not just Isobel, but. "She sometimes gets these blackouts, where she loses time, wakes up in places she doesn't remember going, does stuff she doesn't remember doing. It went away for a while, but flared up near graduation. During one blackout, she did something...really bad. And when she woke up, she was horrified and terrified, and falling apart, and so...I told her I did it." He took another drink. "I told her I messed up, and she stepped right in to 'help' me. Max and I swore we'd never tell her, because she's already so...fragile. I don't know what knowing would do to her. Better she thinks it was me."
Another drink. "But it wrecked all of us, and Max was ready to do something that could have gotten us all hurt even worse. There was this girl...and he was going to tell her stuff we'd promised never to tell anyone. So...Isobel and I decided she needed to go, and Iz made her leave. Convinced her to head off to college early. We thought Max just had a crush, but, now it turns out he's always been crazy in love with her, so...it's possible in trying to help, we ruined his life." And a fourth long drink. "We tell him that, and he'll never forgive us."
He snorted softly. "Gotta tell you - makes me wonder what secret the two of them are keeping from me."
Her eyes follow his to his hand and her smile softens because the way he talks she can tell that there's definitely a story behind how that happened and she has a serious feeling that it involves the mystery man that this conversation is about. Or at least this part of the conversation is about. "The way you talk about him, and the way you sound like you don't want to let it go, it sounds like you love him." Her shoulder brushes his gently with a soft sound. "Relationships aren't easy, and it sounds like there may be some things that he has to work on with or without your help though. But it's not terrible to hope or want to be able to have that person to lean on while you heal, and to help heal in return either."
Sometimes life threw curveballs, took away what it had granted. But he was still here, still moving forward. And while some options might have passed, it isn't like there wouldn't be new possibilities in the future. And when there were, hopefully, he could take them.
Sansa nods a little as she takes the information about Isobel, letting her eyes lift to the sky. "That's a hard secret to keep. It shows how strong you are, to take the burden from her to keep her safe for all these years. And I can understand the worry if she's not strong enough what it might do to her if she found out that it was really her, what it might make her think about herself." She looks back at him, understanding in her green depths. "But at some point, the truth usually comes out, whether you mean it to or not. If you tell her, at least you can control how she finds out about it." Because that's important too.
Giving a slow breath, Sansa let the silence fall for a moment because that was heavier. Scarying or shoving away someone in the hopes it's for the best for the person you care about is tricky. "If he's still healthy, still landed on his feet, I wouldn't go so far to say ruined his life. And you and your sister were doing it out of your love for him, after some time to process it, I'd hope he would realize you weren't intending to hurt him, but protect him. Heart being in the right place kind of a deal." At least, she'd hope that his brother would eventually see it that way.
"That kind of sounds like enough secrets just in those two that hopefully there isn't anything else." She offers a wry smile for that last part to him.
He doesn't protest her assessment of the state of his heart, lips quirking in a self-deprecating smile as he leans back against that shoulder brush a bit. He isolates himself so much from everyone except Isobel, no ties except them, after Alex went to war. Hooking up with tourists took care of some needs, sure, but didn't do much for aching loneliness. "Not gonna deny it. Been hung up on him for a decade, and, yeah. Maybe I do wish it would work, but. He's walked away twice now. I don't think he wants the same thing."
Which meant, maybe, he needs to move on. But kinda hard to do when he's stuck here and has nowhere else to go. Isobel and Max's lives are here, and striking out on his own...doesn't hold a lot of appeal anymore.
"I think we should tell her," he says after a moment. "I told Max, but. He's not having it. And I feel too bad about what we did to defy him like that. I mean, you're not wrong. I just don't know if I can make that call on my own."
He hopes Max will forgive them, if he ever finds out, but he doesn't have a whole lot of faith in that right now, sad as it is. His smile flashes at her again, just as wry. "It does, doesn't it? But if there aren't others, that ends up making me the guy holding all the secrets and that's not all that comfortable, either. I'm just...so tired, y'know?"
no subject
Admitting it was a first step. Maybe he just needed the ability to say it to someone less involved. Though, hiding your heart was easier when you fell into past patterns that made people think you didn't care. That and alcohol. Both were easy. Sansa's happy to give him that ear though, to help him take that step.
"It comes down to what you'd want in the end. Do you want him back, to see if you two could work it out?"
She offered a soft smile. "Sometimes you have to trust that the family bond is stronger than the secrets. If they're all you've got, it means you're all they have too. And even if some time might be needed, family usually gravitates back together after it's healed from any wounds." She nodded in the face of that skeptical look. "I'm sure I really want to hear this."
no subject
Because he wasn't the guy who got the happy ending. Nothing had ever worked out for him, and everything that gave a promise of hope was snatched away the second he reached for it. A safe home. College. Alex.
He took the bottle back, taking a much longer swallow. "When we were kids, a lot of...traumatic shit went down. One particular piece of it left Isobel scarred." Not just Isobel, but. "She sometimes gets these blackouts, where she loses time, wakes up in places she doesn't remember going, does stuff she doesn't remember doing. It went away for a while, but flared up near graduation. During one blackout, she did something...really bad. And when she woke up, she was horrified and terrified, and falling apart, and so...I told her I did it." He took another drink. "I told her I messed up, and she stepped right in to 'help' me. Max and I swore we'd never tell her, because she's already so...fragile. I don't know what knowing would do to her. Better she thinks it was me."
Another drink. "But it wrecked all of us, and Max was ready to do something that could have gotten us all hurt even worse. There was this girl...and he was going to tell her stuff we'd promised never to tell anyone. So...Isobel and I decided she needed to go, and Iz made her leave. Convinced her to head off to college early. We thought Max just had a crush, but, now it turns out he's always been crazy in love with her, so...it's possible in trying to help, we ruined his life." And a fourth long drink. "We tell him that, and he'll never forgive us."
He snorted softly. "Gotta tell you - makes me wonder what secret the two of them are keeping from me."
no subject
Sometimes life threw curveballs, took away what it had granted. But he was still here, still moving forward. And while some options might have passed, it isn't like there wouldn't be new possibilities in the future. And when there were, hopefully, he could take them.
Sansa nods a little as she takes the information about Isobel, letting her eyes lift to the sky. "That's a hard secret to keep. It shows how strong you are, to take the burden from her to keep her safe for all these years. And I can understand the worry if she's not strong enough what it might do to her if she found out that it was really her, what it might make her think about herself." She looks back at him, understanding in her green depths. "But at some point, the truth usually comes out, whether you mean it to or not. If you tell her, at least you can control how she finds out about it." Because that's important too.
Giving a slow breath, Sansa let the silence fall for a moment because that was heavier. Scarying or shoving away someone in the hopes it's for the best for the person you care about is tricky. "If he's still healthy, still landed on his feet, I wouldn't go so far to say ruined his life. And you and your sister were doing it out of your love for him, after some time to process it, I'd hope he would realize you weren't intending to hurt him, but protect him. Heart being in the right place kind of a deal." At least, she'd hope that his brother would eventually see it that way.
"That kind of sounds like enough secrets just in those two that hopefully there isn't anything else." She offers a wry smile for that last part to him.
no subject
Which meant, maybe, he needs to move on. But kinda hard to do when he's stuck here and has nowhere else to go. Isobel and Max's lives are here, and striking out on his own...doesn't hold a lot of appeal anymore.
"I think we should tell her," he says after a moment. "I told Max, but. He's not having it. And I feel too bad about what we did to defy him like that. I mean, you're not wrong. I just don't know if I can make that call on my own."
He hopes Max will forgive them, if he ever finds out, but he doesn't have a whole lot of faith in that right now, sad as it is. His smile flashes at her again, just as wry. "It does, doesn't it? But if there aren't others, that ends up making me the guy holding all the secrets and that's not all that comfortable, either. I'm just...so tired, y'know?"